Carrie Underwood is reportedly questioning her return to American Idol for a second season as a judge. According to sources cited by Star Magazine, the country music superstar has expressed uncertainty about continuing in the high-pressure role—despite her legacy as the show’s most successful alum.

Now 42, Underwood has made it clear to producers that she is not fully committed to coming back. One insider shared that she has voiced concerns to network bosses and hasn’t yet decided if it’s worth the effort.

Underwood, who won Idol back in 2005, stepped into the judging role recently and faced a mixed reception. While fans enjoyed her honest critiques and star power, the position reportedly took a toll behind the scenes.

Motherhood and money factor into Carrie’s hesitation

The Grammy winner and mother of two with former NHL player Mike Fisher has openly discussed the difficulty of balancing her career with family life. She once admitted that she feels guilty about nearly every parenting decision she makes. That ongoing struggle has played a big part in her indecision.

Producers did their best to accommodate her schedule, even allowing dedicated family time during filming. That flexibility was seen as a major perk for Underwood, said the insider.

But there’s another factor reportedly stirring tension—money. Katy Perry, who previously held the judging seat, was paid around $25 million for her role. Underwood, however, was reportedly offered less than half of that. Sources say the pay gap has left the Before He Cheats singer feeling undervalued.

There’s ongoing chatter that Underwood may be using her uncertain future as leverage for a more lucrative deal. The insider noted that she’s had a rocky time on set, and without a better offer, she may feel the position just isn’t worth the stress.

Producers face decision fatigue as Underwood weighs her future

While fans continue to wonder about Underwood’s fate on the show, insiders say producers are also left guessing. The network is reportedly eager to secure her return but hasn’t received a firm commitment.

Adding to the pressure, producers understand that Underwood’s involvement brings prestige and credibility to the show. However, they may also need to weigh whether keeping her on board is feasible if her heart isn’t fully in it.

For now, Carrie Underwood remains in limbo. She’s a music icon and a busy mother, facing the kind of high-stakes decision that even American Idol hopefuls can relate to—choosing between passion, pressure, and personal peace.

Whether or not she returns next season, fans will be watching closely. And if her next move includes stepping away, it won’t be without reason.