Carrie Underwood Is Pregnant With Baby No. 3 — But It’s WHO Told Her Before The Test Was Positive That’s Freaking Fans Out

Country music superstar Carrie Underwood has once again captured the attention of fans worldwide with rumors swirling about a potential third pregnancy. The American Idol alum, known for her powerful vocals and heartfelt lyrics, is no stranger to making headlines, both for her music and her personal life. However, this time, it’s not just the possibility of a new addition to her family with husband Mike Fisher that has fans buzzing—it’s the mysterious circumstances surrounding how she reportedly learned of the pregnancy before even taking a test. While no official confirmation has come from Underwood herself as of August 5, 2025, the speculation is fueled by recent performances, cryptic social media posts, and an intriguing story about an unexpected source predicting her pregnancy.

A History of Heartfelt Family Moments

Carrie Underwood, 42, and her husband, retired NHL player Mike Fisher, 45, are already proud parents to two sons, Isaiah Michael, born in 2015, and Jacob Bryan, born in 2019. The couple, married since 2010, has been open about their journey to parenthood, which has not been without its challenges. Underwood has shared in interviews, including a candid 2018 CBS Sunday Morning segment, that she suffered three miscarriages between 2017 and 2018 before welcoming Jacob. These experiences shaped her perspective on motherhood, making her all the more grateful for her “miracle” sons.

Underwood’s openness about her struggles has endeared her to fans, who admire her resilience and authenticity. In a 2019 interview with The Guardian, she reflected on the pain of her losses, saying, “I will always mourn those children, those lives that were a shooting star, a breath of smoke, but I have Jacob, and he is incredible.” Her ability to channel personal pain into her music, as seen in her album Cry Pretty, has only deepened her connection with her audience.

Now, as rumors of a third pregnancy circulate, fans are revisiting Underwood’s past statements about expanding her family. In a 2019 Today Show interview, shortly after Jacob’s birth, she was asked about the possibility of a third child. “I do not know at this point,” she said, noting the difficulties of her previous pregnancies. “It’s been such a difficult road to get where we are now. I’ll have to evaluate after this tour is over.” While Underwood has not recently addressed the topic directly, her fans are convinced that recent clues point to baby number three.

The Spark That Ignited the Rumors

The speculation began in late 2024 and early 2025, when Underwood appeared at high-profile events, including her performance on Nate Bargatze’s Nashville Christmas special and New Year’s Rockin’ Eve. Fans noticed her choice of looser, more flowing outfits, such as a puffy red minidress during the Christmas special, which some described as “a little off for the occasion.” Social media erupted with comments like, “Nice legs for sure, but for some reason, I think she should have worn stretchy pants for this one,” hinting at a possible baby bump. Similarly, her New Year’s Rockin’ Eve performance featured a baggy ensemble that sparked further chatter on platforms like X, where fans debated whether she was concealing a pregnancy.

These observations align with Underwood’s history of carefully timed pregnancy announcements. When expecting her second child, Jacob, she waited until her baby bump was noticeable before sharing the news on Instagram in August 2018, explaining, “I was like, ‘I guess today’s the day. I can’t hide this anymore.’” Fans are now wondering if she’s employing a similar strategy, keeping a third pregnancy under wraps until the right moment.

The Mysterious Messenger

What’s truly “freaking fans out” is the story circulating on social media and entertainment blogs about who reportedly told Underwood she was pregnant before she even took a test. According to unverified posts on X and fan discussions, a close friend or family member—some speculate it could be her son Isaiah, now 10, or even a spiritual advisor—predicted her pregnancy with uncanny accuracy. The rumor suggests this person approached Underwood with a gut feeling or a dream, insisting she was expecting before she had any physical symptoms or a positive test. While no concrete evidence supports this claim, the idea of a premonition-like revelation has sent fans into a frenzy, with many calling it “spooky” or “divinely inspired.”

This narrative resonates with Underwood’s own reflections on faith and intuition. In her 2018 CBS interview, she described a moment of emotional clarity during her pregnancy with Jacob, when she prayed and expressed anger at God after fearing another miscarriage. To her relief, a doctor’s visit confirmed the pregnancy was healthy. Fans are now drawing parallels, wondering if this mysterious prediction could be another instance of Underwood’s deep spiritual connection guiding her journey.

Balancing Career and Motherhood

If Underwood is indeed pregnant, the timing would align with her continued ability to juggle her thriving career and family life. As a judge on American Idol—a role she took on in 2024, replacing Katy Perry—she’s been praised as a “godsend” by the show’s crew, bringing a calm presence after years of turbulence. Her recent performances, including appearances at the Grand Ole Opry and upcoming tour dates, showcase her relentless work ethic.

Underwood has also spoken about prioritizing her family, often bringing Isaiah and Jacob on tour and making frequent trips home to their Tennessee estate. In a 2022 Today Show interview, she explained, “This tour, I’m going home a lot more than I ever have before. If there’s a way to get me home, even if it’s just for the day.” A third child would undoubtedly add complexity to this balance, but Underwood’s history suggests she’s more than capable of rising to the challenge.

Fan Reactions and What’s Next

The lack of official confirmation hasn’t stopped fans from speculating wildly on social media. Posts on X range from excitement—“Carrie Underwood pregnant with baby #3?! I’m screaming!”—to skepticism, with some urging caution until Underwood herself speaks out. The story of someone predicting her pregnancy has only amplified the buzz, with fans sharing theories about whether it was a family member, a psychic, or even a divine sign.

Underwood’s past pregnancies have been celebrated with heartfelt Instagram posts, like the one announcing Jacob’s birth: “Jacob Bryan Fisher entered the world in the wee hours of the morning on Monday… his mom, dad, and big brother couldn’t be happier.” If she is expecting, fans can likely expect a similar announcement, possibly tied to a major event like the American Idol premiere on March 9, 2025, or a tour milestone.

For now, Underwood remains focused on her music and family, with no public comment on the pregnancy rumors. Whether or not baby number three is on the way, her fans are captivated by the possibility—and the mysterious figure who may have seen it coming first. As one X user put it, “If Carrie’s pregnant and someone knew before the test, that’s next-level wild.” Until Underwood confirms or denies the speculation, the country star’s devoted fanbase will keep watching her every move, eagerly awaiting the next chapter in her remarkable journey.