😱 OH MY!! Greg Gutfeld STOPS SHOW After Jessica Tarlov’s UNFORGIVABLE Mistake LIVE!
Fox News’ The Five erupts as Jessica Tarlov’s shocking blunder forces Greg Gutfeld to halt the show! What did she say to spark this chaos?
👀 Click to uncover the jaw-dropping moment shaking the airwaves!

Fox News’ The Five is known for its lively debates, where co-hosts Greg Gutfeld and Jessica Tarlov often clash over political hot topics. A recent claim alleges that Gutfeld stopped the entire show after Tarlov made an “unforgivable mistake” live on air, sparking a frenzy online. YouTube videos with titles like “OH MY!! Greg Gutfeld STOPS THE ENTIRE SHOW After Jessica Tarlov Makes UNFORGIVABLE Mistake LIVE” have fueled speculation, but credible sources, including Mediaite and Snopes, provide no evidence of a show-stopping incident or a specific “unforgivable mistake” by Tarlov. The claim appears to stem from sensationalized social media and YouTube content, likely exaggerating past on-air clashes between the two. This article explores Gutfeld and Tarlov’s dynamic, their documented disputes, the alleged incident, and the broader context, separating fact from rumor.

Greg Gutfeld and Jessica Tarlov: A Combustible Dynamic

Greg Gutfeld, born September 12, 1964, in San Mateo, California, is a comedian, author, and host of Gutfeld! and co-host of The Five on Fox News. A University of California, Berkeley graduate, Gutfeld’s career spans editing Men’s Health and Maxim UK, hosting Red Eye (2007–2015), and becoming a late-night ratings leader with Gutfeld!, surpassing The Late Show with Stephen Colbert in August 2021. Known for his sharp humor and conservative views, Gutfeld often spars with liberal co-host Jessica Tarlov, a political strategist with a PhD from the London School of Economics. Tarlov, who joined The Five in 2022, is a frequent defender of Democratic policies, creating tension with Gutfeld’s provocative style. Their debates, covering issues like Trump’s policies and economic plans, are a staple of the show’s appeal.

Past clashes have drawn attention. On July 24, 2023, Tarlov, who is Jewish, challenged Gutfeld over a Florida curriculum suggesting slaves developed skills for personal benefit, comparing it to Holocaust narratives. Gutfeld invoked Viktor Frankl’s Man’s Search for Meaning, implying Holocaust survivors needed skills to endure, a comment Tarlov found inflammatory. Another heated exchange occurred on July 16, 2024, when Tarlov returned from maternity leave and pushed back against Gutfeld’s claim that Democrats’ “threat to democracy” rhetoric incited an assassination attempt on Trump. Tarlov cited Trump’s own inflammatory language, like a fundraising email calling Biden a threat, prompting Gutfeld to dismiss her examples as “hilarious.” These moments highlight their contentious dynamic but don’t indicate a show-stopping event.

The Alleged “Unforgivable Mistake”

The claim that Gutfeld stopped The Five after Tarlov’s “unforgivable mistake” originates from YouTube videos posted between August 2024 and July 2025, with titles like “Greg Gutfeld STOPS The Show After Jessica Tarlov Makes Fatal Mistake Live” and “Jessica Tarlov TAKEN OFF SET By Fox Producers After BRUTAL fight with Greg Gutfeld LIVE!” These videos, from channels like LVNation and ScandalScoop, suggest a dramatic incident, but Snopes and Lead Stories debunk similar claims as fictional, noting AI-generated thumbnails and disclaimers admitting “entertainment” purposes. No credible outlet, including Mediaite or Fox News, confirms a specific incident where Gutfeld halted the show or Tarlov was removed.

The rumor may exaggerate a real clash, such as the April 16, 2025, episode where Tarlov challenged Gutfeld for downplaying the wrongful deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia to a Salvadoran prison under Trump’s administration. Gutfeld argued the error was minor compared to border issues under Biden, saying, “At worst, a guy gets sent to a country he doesn’t want to go to—I can live with that.” Tarlov retorted, “Into a prison camp? Not just out into the wild,” highlighting a constitutional crisis. While heated, the exchange didn’t stop the show or result in Tarlov’s removal, as Yahoo reported a standard debate. Another possible source is a July 2025 discussion on Kamala Harris’ price gouging ban, where Gutfeld criticized her timing, and Tarlov likely defended Democratic policies, though no reports confirm a show-stopping moment.

The Role of Social Media and YouTube

Social media has amplified the rumor. An X post from @niceblackdude on July 24, 2025, claimed Gutfeld “obliterated” Tarlov over an Obama-related conspiracy, stating she was “saved” by a Trump AI speech, but the linked video lacks evidence of a show stoppage. Other X posts by Tarlov, like one on August 2, 2025, criticizing Trump’s election rigging claims, suggest she remained active on The Five without incident. YouTube channels often use clickbait titles, like those in July 2025, to capitalize on Gutfeld and Tarlov’s known friction. Snopes notes these videos rely on exaggerated narratives, similar to debunked claims about Joy Behar’s firing from The View. The lack of specific details—such as the nature of Tarlov’s “mistake”—further undermines the claim’s credibility.

Public and Media Reaction

The rumor reflects polarized reactions to The Five’s dynamic. Conservative X users praise Gutfeld’s takedowns, with one stating, “Greg Gutfeld destroys Tarlov every time she opens her mouth,” while liberal users defend Tarlov’s role as a counterpoint, with one noting, “Jessica’s the only one making sense on that show.” The controversy aligns with The Five’s appeal: heated debates that drive ratings. Mediaite reported the show’s strong viewership in 2024, averaging 3 million viewers, with Gutfeld’s provocative style a key draw. However, no major outlet confirms a show-stopping incident, and Fox News has not addressed the YouTube claims, suggesting they lack substance.

The rumor’s spread mirrors past The Five controversies, like Gutfeld’s 2023 Holocaust comment, which drew ADL criticism but didn’t halt the show. Tarlov’s maternity leave absence in early 2024 fueled similar speculation about her exit, debunked when she returned in July 2024. The “unforgivable mistake” narrative fits a pattern of sensationalized content targeting The Five’s audience, capitalizing on Gutfeld’s reputation for sharp retorts and Tarlov’s liberal stance.

Separating Fact from Fiction

The claim that Greg Gutfeld stopped The Five after Jessica Tarlov’s “unforgivable mistake” is unsupported by credible sources. Verified clashes, like the April 2025 deportation debate or July 2023 curriculum dispute, show heated exchanges but no show-stopping incident or Tarlov’s removal. YouTube videos and X posts exaggerate these moments for clicks, with Snopes and Lead Stories debunking similar claims as fictional. Tarlov’s active presence on The Five, as seen in her August 2025 X posts, confirms her ongoing role. The real story lies in their documented debates—contentious but routine—not a fabricated crisis. The scandal’s appeal stems from The Five’s polarized dynamic, not a singular “unforgivable” error.

Conclusion: A Rumor-Fueled Frenzy

Greg Gutfeld and Jessica Tarlov’s clashes on The Five are a ratings driver, but the claim that Gutfeld stopped the show over Tarlov’s “unforgivable mistake” is a sensationalized myth. Fueled by YouTube clickbait and X posts, the narrative exaggerates their real but routine debates, like those over Trump’s policies or Harris’ economic plans. As The Five continues to thrive, the focus should be on its verified discussions—Gutfeld’s provocations and Tarlov’s counterpoints—not unverified claims of chaos. To understand this saga, look to credible reports from Mediaite and Yahoo, not speculative social media hype.