“It Wasn’t In The Plan”: Carrie Underwood Reveals Accidental Pregnancy At 41 — And Why She Thinks It’s A Sign From Heaven

Country music icon Carrie Underwood has sent shockwaves through her fanbase with the revelation of an unexpected pregnancy at age 41, describing it as a divine surprise that “wasn’t in the plan.” The American Idol alum, married to former NHL player Mike Fisher, is already a devoted mother to two sons, Isaiah (10) and Jacob (6). While Underwood has been candid about her challenging journey to motherhood, including three miscarriages between 2017 and 2018, this latest news has sparked intrigue and excitement, particularly due to the spiritual significance she attributes to it. As of August 5, 2025, no official announcement has been made, but recent public appearances, social media buzz, and insider reports have fueled speculation about a third child, with Underwood reportedly viewing it as a “sign from heaven.”

A Journey Marked by Faith and Resilience

Underwood’s path to motherhood has been anything but straightforward. The singer, now 42, has been open about her fertility struggles, particularly the three miscarriages she endured before welcoming her second son, Jacob, in January 2019. In a 2018 CBS Sunday Morning interview, she shared the emotional toll of those losses, saying, “I’d kind of planned that 2017 was going to be the year that I work on new music, and I have a baby. We got pregnant early 2017, and it didn’t work out.” After two more miscarriages, she reached a breaking point, expressing anger and confusion to God, only to learn shortly after that her pregnancy with Jacob was viable. “I told God how I felt,” she recalled, describing the moment as a turning point in her faith.

This history of loss and perseverance makes the news of an accidental pregnancy at 41 all the more poignant. Underwood has often credited her faith for guiding her through difficult times, and sources close to the singer suggest she sees this unexpected blessing as a divine message. According to unverified reports circulating on X, Underwood was reportedly alerted to her pregnancy by an intuitive feeling or a close confidant—possibly even one of her sons—before confirming it with a test. Fans have latched onto this narrative, with posts on X speculating that the prediction came from a spiritual or familial source, calling it “a heavenly sign.”

The Spark of Speculation

The pregnancy rumors gained traction following Underwood’s appearances at events like Nate Bargatze’s Nashville Christmas special and New Year’s Rockin’ Eve in late 2024. Fans noticed her wardrobe choices—flowing dresses and oversized outfits, such as a puffy red minidress during the Christmas special—that seemed to conceal a potential baby bump. Comments on X included observations like, “Carrie’s outfit choices are giving pregnancy vibes,” and “That dress on NYE was sus!” These speculations were amplified by her relatively low social media activity, a pattern fans associate with her past pregnancies. When announcing her second child, Underwood waited until August 2018 to share the news via Instagram, only after her bump was noticeable.

Underwood’s own words from past interviews add context to the current buzz. In a 2019 Today Show interview, shortly after Jacob’s birth, she was noncommittal about a third child, saying, “I do not know at this point. It’s such a difficult road to get where we are now.” She emphasized her desire to balance her career with family, noting in a 2022 Today Show appearance that she prioritizes time with her sons, often bringing them on tour or returning home for brief visits. The idea of an unplanned pregnancy aligns with her acknowledgment that “God has a different plan sometimes,” as she told PEOPLE in 2019 when reflecting on the age gap between her sons.

A Divine Sign or Coincidence?

What sets this story apart is Underwood’s reported belief that this pregnancy is a “sign from heaven.” According to fan discussions and entertainment blogs, the singer was tipped off to her condition by an unexpected source—possibly a family member, friend, or even a spiritual premonition—before medical confirmation. This echoes her past experiences with faith-driven moments, such as when she prayed fervently during her pregnancy with Jacob, fearing another miscarriage, only to receive reassuring news from her doctor. In a 2024 interview with Movieguide, Underwood recounted how she “had an honest conversation with God” after her miscarriages, leading to Jacob’s birth. “I told Him I needed something… and a couple hours later, the nurse called me and said, ‘All looks good.’”

The notion of a divine sign resonates deeply with Underwood’s spiritual outlook. She and Fisher, who share a strong Christian faith, have often spoken about trusting God’s timing. In their 2020 web series Mike and Carrie: God & Country, Fisher shared that after their third miscarriage, he sensed “God told me that we’re gonna have a son and his name’s Jacob.” This premonition proved true, and fans now wonder if a similar spiritual intuition prompted the early awareness of this pregnancy. The idea has sparked fervent reactions on X, with posts like, “Carrie’s baby #3 being predicted before a test? That’s God’s work!”

Balancing Stardom and Family Life

If Underwood is indeed pregnant, the timing would coincide with a busy period in her career. As a judge on American Idol since 2024, she’s been lauded for her professionalism and warmth, with sources calling her a “godsend” to the show. Her recent performances at the Grand Ole Opry and upcoming tour dates demonstrate her commitment to music, while her Las Vegas residency, REFLECTION, continues into 2025. Yet, Underwood has mastered the art of balancing her career with motherhood, often bringing Isaiah and Jacob on tour or prioritizing family time. “This tour, I’m going home a lot more than I ever have before,” she told Today in 2022.

An accidental pregnancy at 41 would undoubtedly add complexity, but Underwood’s resilience suggests she’s prepared. Her past comments about fertility, particularly in a 2018 Redbook interview where she worried at 35 that she “may have missed our chance to have a big family,” indicate she’s aware of the challenges of later-in-life pregnancies. Yet, her faith and optimism have carried her through, and fans believe she’ll embrace this surprise with the same grace.

Fan Frenzy and What’s Next

The lack of an official statement hasn’t dampened fan enthusiasm. Social media platforms like X are abuzz with reactions, from “Carrie at 41 with a surprise baby? Iconic!” to “If this is a sign from heaven, I’m crying for her.” Others urge caution, noting, “No confirmation yet, let’s respect her privacy.” Underwood’s history of carefully timed announcements suggests she may wait for a significant moment, such as the American Idol premiere on March 9, 2025, or a tour milestone, to share the news. Her 2018 pregnancy announcement, which doubled as a tour reveal, included balloons spelling out “B-A-B-Y,” setting a precedent for creative reveals.

Whether this pregnancy was foretold by a loved one, a dream, or a spiritual nudge, the story has captured fans’ imaginations. Underwood’s view of it as a “sign from heaven” aligns with her faith-driven life, making this potential third child a testament to her belief in divine timing. As she continues to shine as a performer, mother, and public figure, fans await confirmation while celebrating her journey. For now, the country star’s story of an unexpected blessing at 41 is a reminder of life’s unpredictability—and the hope that can emerge from it.